Fresh out of college and full of hope, I stepped into a full-time youth pastor position at a rapidly growing church. My first service with the teens drew about ten students. The main sanctuary was packed, but the small youth group was in a stage of rebuilding. I knew a surge was coming; I just had to be ready for it.

Jesus didn't say "Well done, good and faithful servant" to the one who waited until the crowd arrived. He said it to the one already at work with what he had.

Maybe your youth group has five teens. Maybe you're starting from scratch, but you can see who's coming, kids in children's ministry aging up, families joining the church, and housing developments being built in your community. Somewhere between the excitement of what's next and who's coming, you find yourself asking: What do I do until they get here?

The answer is simpler than you think: Start with what you have for those already there.

Building your youth ministry strategy before the crowd arrives

Write the vision—make it plain

Remember Habakkuk? He received a word from God when it looked like little was progressing. The answer wasn't "wait,” it was "write." Write the vision. Make it plain on tablets, so that a runner can read it. For the vision awaits its appointed time. It will not lie. If it seems slow, wait for it. It will surely come. (Habakkuk 2:2–3)

This Bible passage is more than a motivational statement. It's a ministry strategy written for the runner, not the resting reader. That means you need to look at what's already moving.

Count the children in your 4^th- and 5^th-grade children’s ministry. Examine the demographics of families moving into the neighborhood. Visit the schools nearby. Those kids are the vision, and their arrival is the appointed time. What does the children's ministry roster reveal about who's coming? What do the housing trends say about how you should prepare?

Take notes before those same 4^th- and 5^th-graders move from the children's ministry to the folding chairs in your youth room.

Write down who is coming soon. That’s the vision.

Write out what you believe about student ministry and where you want it to go. That’s the plan.

Identify your leadership roles, discipleship strategy, and teaching approach. Keep it simple, but put it on paper. Build your plan so that when they run in, there's somewhere for them to go.

Honor the young people you already have

I once sat on a panel with youth leaders and students discussing why teens leave the church. One young woman shared that she enjoyed being there, but every week her youth leader asked the group who they had invited. She looked around and said quietly, "Am I good enough?"

It's tempting to give less when numbers are low. Why plan a full-year curriculum for four kids? Why hold a parent meeting or leadership training for a handful of students? Think of the fable about an ant that worked diligently, without a crowd, without applause, without anyone looking over its shoulder. It just worked faithfully, preparing for a harvest it couldn't yet see. That is the image of a youth worker with a few teens in front of them and big plans inside them.

The teens God has entrusted to your care matter right now. They have names, stories, fears, hopes, and faith being shaped, with or without your investment. Big ministry is already happening at your church. The question is whether you see it that way.

Honor the young people you have. Give those teens your best: a well-developed curriculum, a safe environment to grow, and intentional programming that helps them understand their identity, belonging, and purpose. The ant doesn't wait for a bigger colony to start working. Neither should you.

Build before the harvest

In the parable of the talents, a master entrusted his servants with resources before leaving on a journey. When he returned, he didn't just comment on the results of the faithful servants, he commented on their effort: "Well done, good and faithful servant. You have been faithful over a little; I will set you over much." (Matthew 25:21)

Faithful over a little. That's the standard.

Start now: 3 actions to prepare your small youth group for growth

Here are three things you can build before the bigger harvest arrives:

A student pathway.

When a teen first walks through the door of your ministry, what do they experience? Where do they get connected? What do you want them to know about Jesus and about life by the time they graduate? You don't need a complex system, just a clear, written vision for the journey you're inviting students into.

A team.

Who in your congregation has a heart for teens? Who excels in areas where you're weaker? Don't limit your search to any particular age group; older members can be tremendous sources of support. Invite people into the vision now, before the numbers justify it. When you build your team in advance, you're not scrambling when the harvest comes.

A parent and caregiver culture.

At FYI, we say relationships move at the speed of trust. Your current parents and caregivers are your most valuable feedback loop and your strongest future promoters. Build real relationships now. Poll them about their hopes and expectations. Show them, consistently, that their child matters to you beyond Sunday morning. That trust pays dividends you can't fully anticipate.

Serving your teenagers well right now

When the master in Jesus' parable distributed resources, it was never about the quantity; it was about stewardship. The "little" Jesus speaks of is opportunity. Whether you have one student, five, or five hundred, you've been given the opportunity to steward what's in front of you.

If you're faithful with ministering to one, you can be faithful ministering to many. Right now, you have the rare gift of knowing every teen by name, knowing their story, and praying for each one individually. That is faithful ministry.

One day, the room will be full. The energy will be electric. And I pray that in that moment, you look back and give thanks for what God built, because “overnight” is always built over time.

The "well done" you receive won't happen the day the room fills up. It's being earned right now, with the few you have.

The vision awaits its appointed time. It will surely come.

Start now. Be faithful with what you have. The rest is coming.

Turn your best ministry ideas into reality with a dynamic team plan.

As a ministry leader, you have goals for change in your church, but turning them into action can be a struggle. You want your church to be a vibrant community where people of all ages find community, grow in faith, and thrive. But it’s not always clear how to get from where you are to where you want to be.

Let Fuller Youth Institute’s experienced church consultants come alongside you as you build a team, clarify your vision, and create the unique strategy and timeline so your church can move into the future it longs for.

Find out more