Don’t Talk Back

January 10, 2012

Subscribe Now!

Print Make PDF

In a report with a stellar title, “Why A Teen Who Talks Back May Have A Bright Future,” NPR’s Patti Neighmond recently shared good news for frustrated parents everywhere: all that conflict might lead somewhere positive after all.

According to new research from the University of Virginia, parent-teen arguments should be seen as a “critical training ground” for how to build skills in handling disagreements throughout life. The study followed teenagers and their parents from age 13-16, looking at the way they handled conflict about common issues (grades, chores, money, friends). The researchers noted:

“The teens who learned to be calm and confident and persuasive with their parents acted the same way when they were with their peers,” [lead researcher Joseph P. Allen] says. They were able to confidently disagree, saying ‘no’ when offered alcohol or drugs. In fact, they were 40 percent more likely to say ‘no’ than kids who didn’t argue with their parents… Kids who felt confident to express themselves to their parents also felt confident being honest with their friends.

This doesn’t mean parents should put on boxing gloves and duke out every argument with their kids, but it also doesn’t mean parents should try to squelch conflict (either through overpowering or conceding). Instead, the researchers recommend that parents learn to listen well.  In fact, they found that when parents listened well, their kids (here’s the big payoff) listened back.

Parents who listen foster teenagers who listen.  Sounds like a revolutionary win-win, doesn’t it?

©2012 Fuller Youth Institute

Subscribe Now! Print Back to top
  • Mark

    A couple random thoughts.
    1. I talked back a lot as a kid and as an adult I make a living talking back.

    2. As a parent (and I’m just riffing here)  my kids seem to talk back or bristle when they feel an injustice has been done (almost always to them).  It’s a fine line to walk as a parent to encourage them standing up for injustice and for themselves, but similtaneously helping them see the bigger picture, the injustice they have caused, or their impact of their demands on others.

    3. A few weeks ago, during a time of especially clumbsy 8th grader inattentiveness my son broke something while working with me in the yard.  It was a boneheaded thing he did. Lack of listening to my instructions on what we were doing. Another broken thing because of another boneheaded move in a short amount of time.  I lost my cool and said something like, “Why aren’t you listening? I told you want to do, but you did something else.” (here comes the worst kind of parenting moment) “you break everything you touch!” I walked away frustrated and came back a few minutes later having cooled off. I asked him to continue helping, and he said, “Why? I’m just going to break it.” But there was somethign in the way he said it. He was obviously hurt and some self preservation sort of standing up to dad happening.”  I apologized for saying what I said, followed by some other things.  Then I said, “I’m glad you stood up for yourself.  You are strong and it’s a good thing for you to speak up when you feel like I’ve done something wrong.”  It was a rough moment and I disappointed him and blew it. In some ways we’re still recovering from moments like that. But him standing his ground and talking back is rooted in both the strength of his character and of his ego. 

    As i grow older, I notice that I have a difficult time to this day telling the two apart.

    riddle

  • http://fulleryouthinstitute.org Brad M. Griffin

    Mark, WELL SAID. Thanks for the great story. And yeah, that character/ego question is huge.

    I butt heads with my 9-yr-old over what feels like arguing in a way that disrespects us as parents, but also wonder whether I’ve modeled disrespect more than respect in the way I’ve corrected/disciplined her for her mistakes. It’s much easier said than done to harness a conflict for positive learning when our own hot buttons are pushed in the midst of the argument…and they nearly always are.

  • Pingback: Don’t Talk Back | Fuller Youth Institute | The Narrow Road

  • Pingback: Arguing with your parents is good!?! « Bel Air Youth Discipleship

  • Sarah Rose

     She can’t be nine already!!  Thanks for your encouragement along this parenting journey!

Latest Blog Entry